Magic,
I'm sure there are plenty of Melbourne horses that have'nt performed in the past and there will be plenty in the future.I am only making my assesment based on the facts that are as plain as day for all to see, if you disagree, fine, that's entirely up to you. Obviously you are a fan of the horse, there is no other reason why you would stick up for him as you are, when his G1 winning record here is less than complimentary compared with Sydney. if you feel compelled to let me know about these Melbourne horses please do and if the facts are as clear cut as mine you will get no argument from me.Unlike your good self, I can admit when certain horses, are not up to certain tasks. At least not to date anyway.